Publishers of products that lift, inspire, inform and entertain, to the LDS & general marketplace, since 1971.

Best Sellers m||m Upcoming Projects m||m Instructions for Authors
Shipping: USA m||m Shipping: Overseas

HorizonPublishers-Bookstore.com is the official website for retail internet sales of all Horizon Publishers' products. We stock and ship all Frontlist and Backlist items.

Religious Subjects
Angels, Life After Death
Books in Spanish
Children: LDS
Cross Stitch: LDS
Defense of the LDS Faith
Doctrine & Theology: LDS
Family Life & Parenting
Fiction: LDS
History, Biographies: LDS
Inspirational, Self Help
Leadership
Marriage, Weddings
Missionary Work
Music: Piano & Choral
Prophecy & Last Days
Recorded Books
Scripture Studies
Talk Tapes, CDs
Temples, Genealogy

General Subjects
Camping, Hunting, Survival
Choral Concepts
Christmas, Holidays
Cooking & Recipes
Cross Stitch & Sewing
Disaster Readiness
Dutch Oven, Camp Cooking
Education
Food Storage
Gardening
History, Biography
Miscellaneous
Personal Development
Scouting, Outdoor Crafts
Utah & the West


 

Teaching Choral Concepts

 

 

 

 

The Legacy of the Brass Plates of Laban--
A Comparison of Biblical and Book of Mormon Texts

by H. Clay Gorton

 

Review

     The Legacy of the Brass Plates of Laban is an in-depth study of the differences between the Book of Mormon and King James Bible Isaiah texts.

     Seventeen of the 20 Book of Mormon Isaiah chapters are from Joseph Smith's translation of the actual copy that Nephi made directly from the Brass Plates of Laban. The other three chapters were from Mormon's abridgement of the words of Abinadi (Mosiah 14) and from the words of the Savior (3 Nephi 2 and 22).

     Since the brass plates of Laban were in existence prior to 600 B.C., the Book of Mormon Isaiah is the most ancient scriptural record of Isaiah's writings in existence. It is taken in this work as the standard from which the biblical accounts are evaluated.

     In this work the author makes a meticulous word-by-word comparison of the 404 verses in the 20 Isaiah chapters, identifying each instance where the wording is not identical. The comparison clearly demonstrates that the Book of Mormon Isaiah is, as it claims to be, a copy of an ancient manuscript which predates all the other manuscript versions of Isaiah. This comparison provides convincing evidence that the Book of Mormon is a true historical document and that the Prophet Joseph Smith was inspired in its translation.

     The differences between the Book of Mormon and King James versions are compared with English translations of the Greek Septuagint, the Latin Vulgate and the Hebrew Masoretic texts. The author has found that 115 of the 348 differences between the Book of Mormon and Bible texts actually alter the meaning of the passages. These differences, far from being random variations resulting from inadvertent scribal errors, clearly indicate that the King James and other Bible versions contain intentional deviations from the original meaning-deviations designed to justify Israel in its apostate beliefs and practices. A number of chiasma common to the two accounts give clear evidence of Book of Mormon supremacy, as they are found degraded in the King James version.

     It is further conclusively shown that the Book of Isaiah was an intact writing prior to 600 B.C., which forcefully negates the claims of the higher critics that the Book of Isaiah was a compilation of multiple authors in post-Isaianic times.

     This book is a powerful aid to the understanding of the Isaiah message and should be welcome addition to the libraries of both the serious student and the casual reader.

 

Table of Contents

                Part One: Evaluation and Significance of the Isaiah Variations

Introduction, 11
Testing the Authenticity of the Book of Mormon, 11
The Book of Mormon: A Prime Old Testament Source, 12
Comparisons Made in This Book, 12

1. The Brass Plates of Laban, 14
   A Description of the Book of Mormon Records, 14
   The Great Worth of the Brass Plates, 15
   The Contents of the Brass Plates, 16
   The Antiquity of the Brass Plates, 17
   Why Were the Brass Plates Written in Egyptian?, 18
   The Brass Plates as Part of the Nephite Record, 19

2. The Challenge of Translating Correctly, 23
   Obstacles to Correctly Conveying the Original Intent, 23
   Transliteration, 23
   Each Language Has a Unique Grammatical Structure, 24
   Words With Different Meanings in Different Languages and Contexts, 24
   Vocal Inflections Change Meanings, 25
   The Rich Nuances of Synonyms and Idiomatic Expressions, 26
   Many Textual Variations Can Express the Same Thought, 26
   The Qumran Scrolls Revealed Hebrew Pronunciations, 29
   Joseph Smith Translated an Unknown Language, 29
   Use of the Urim and Thummim, 30
   Did the Urim and Thummim Convey Words or Thoughts?, 30
   King James Isaiah Used as a Model, 31
   Stylistic and Substantive Changes, 31
   Statistical Insights, 32
   Alteration of the Scriptures Foretold in Prophecy, 32

3. Biblical Texts, 34
   Comparison of First and Subsequent Editions of the Book of Mormon,  34
   The Joseph Smith Translation of the Bible, 38
   The Manuscript Lineage of the King James Version of the Bible, 39
   Comparison Texts Utilized in This Work, 41
   Bible Isaiah Reflects Apostate Condition of Israel, 43
   Statistical Considerations and Tables, 44
   KJ Changes to the B of M Text, 45
   KJ Additions to the Hebrew Text, 47
   The B of M Isaiah Refutes the Higher Critics, 49

4. Chiastic Comparisons, 52
   1 Nephi 20:1-12 / lsaiah 40:1-12, 53
   1 Nephi 20:13-22 / lsaiah 48:13-22, 57
   1Nephi 21:1-5 / lsaiah49:1-5, 62
   2 Nephi 7:1 / lsaiah 50:1, 64
   Conclusion, 65

5. The Influence of the Apostate Condition of Israel on the Wording of Isaiah, 66
   The Bible Version of Isaiah Tends to Justify Israel in her Apostate Behavior, 68
   The Bible Version of Isaiah Tends to Diminish God's Judgments Against Israel, 75
   The Bible Version of Isaiah Tends to Deflect the Judgments of God Away from the House of Israel, 78
   The Bible Version of Isaiah Diminishes or Denies the power of God, 81

                                   Part Two: Verse by Verse Analysis

6. 1 Nephi 20 / Isaiah 48, 83
   Verse 1--The Doctrine of Baptism Missing from the KJ, 83
   Verse 2--An Accusation Is Changed to a Commendation in the KJ Version, 85
   Verse 3--"Showing or Demonstrating" Former Things Is Changed in the KJ Version to "Doing or Accomplishing Them, 86
   Verse 4--An Action is Changed to a Mere Declaration in the KJ Version, 88
   Verse 5--The Connection Between the Lord's Declaration of His Prior Works and Israel's Obstinacy in Recognizing Them Is Destroyed in the KJ Version, 90
   Verse 6--The Connection to Verse 5 of Israel Being Accused of Idolatry is Destroyed in the KJ Version, 92
   Verse 7--The Meaning of the Verse is Destroyed in the KJ by Deleting a Phrase, 93
   Verse 9--The Context of Israel's Unworthiness Has Been Deleted from the KJ, 95
   Verse 10--The KJ Introduces a Spurious and Confusing Analogy, 96
   Verse 14--A Prophetic Declaration is Deleted from the KJ Version, 99
   Verse 15--Israel's Accountability to God Has Been Deleted in the KJ Version, 101
   Verse 16--By Relocating a Semicolon in the KJ Version, Israel is Removed from its Accountability, 102
   Verse 17--The Deletion of a Phrase from the KJ Weakens the Context of the Verse, 103
   Verse 21--The KJ Clarifies the Intent of the Verse, 106
   Verse 22--Israel's Guilt is Removed in the KJ by Removing a Connecting Phrase, 107

7. 1 Nephi 21 / Isaiah 49, 110
   Verse 1--Reference to the Wicked Pastors of the House of Israel Is Deleted from the KJ, 111
   Verse 7--The Acceptance of Israel by the Lord is Reinforced in the KJ Version, 115
   Verse 8--The Removal of "O isles of the sea" from the KJ Obscures Reference to Dispersed Israel, and the Messiah Is Removed as Chosen for a Covenant of the People, 116
   Verse 12--Reference to the House of Israel Is Again Deleted in the KJ, 119
   Verse 13--The Promise of Blessings upon the Lord's People Is Deleted from the KJ, 120
   Verse 14--Again the Reassurance of Blessings Upon Zion Is Deleted from the KJ Version, 121
   Verse l5--Minor Deletions Weaken the Force of the Message, 122
   Verse 17--The Object of Israel's Victorious Aggression Is Removed from the KJ, 123
   Verse 24--The Deletion of the Conjunction "for" in the KJ Weakens the Narrative Connection, 127

8. 2 Nephi 7 / 1saiah 50, 129
   Verse 1--The Implied Promise of Israel's Reinstatement Is Deleted in the KJ, 130
   Verse 2--A Condemnatory Statement Is Changed to a Question of Incredulity, 131
   Verse 4--Reference to the House of Israel Is Deleted from the KJ Text, 133
   Verse 8--Justification by the Lord and the Defending Action of the Messiah Have Been Deleted From the KJ, 135
   Verse 10--The Implied Guidance of the Lord Is Eliminated by the Addition of a Phrase in the KJ text, 137

9. 2 Nephi 8 / Isaiah 51 and 52:1-2, 141
   Verse 19--Continuity Is Destroyed in the KJ by Changing "Sons" to "Things", 151
   Verse 20--The Concept of Redemption Through the Atonement Has Been Deleted from the KJ, 152

10. 2 Nephi 12 / Isaiah 2, 158
   Verse 5--The Accusation of Wickedness Against Israel Is Eliminated in the KJ, 159
   Verse 6--The KJ Translators Misinterpret the Meaning of the Verse by Changing "listening to soothsayers" "to being soothsayers", 160
   Verse 9--By Eliminating the Negative, the KJ Introduces an Inconsistency, 162
   Verse 10--The KJ Again Removes the Culpability of Israel, 163
   Verse 12--The Universality of the Effect of the Coming of the Lord Is Eliminated in the KJ, 164
   Verse 13--The Concept of Pride as the Reason for Judgment Is Removed in the KJ, 165
   Verse 14--The Allegorical Depiction of Pride is Changed in the KJ to Topology, 166
   Verse 16--A Generalization of the Lord's Judgment Against Israel Is Deleted in the KJ, 167
   Verse 19--Again The KJ Removes the Culpability of Israel, 168
   Verse 21--The KJ Changes Culpability to Adulation, 170

11. 2 Nephi 13 / Isaiah 3, 173
   Verse 6--A Pleading for Protection Is Changed to a Cursing in the KJ, 174
   Verse 9--An Accusation of Guilt Is Changed to a Confession of Guilt in the KJ, 176
   Verse 10--The KJ Changes the "Righteous" from a People to an Individual, 177
   Verse 11--The Punishment Is Diminished, and the Object of the Punishment Is Changed From a People to an Individual, 178
   Verse 15--By Moving a Question Mark, the KJ Changes Condemnation to Incredulity, 180

12. 2 Nephi 14 / Isaiah 4, 184
   Verse 5--Zion as a Protectorate of the Lord Is Deleted in the KJ, 186

13. 2 Nephi 15 / Isaiah 5, 188
   Verse 8--The KJ Adds An Innocuous Metaphor, 191

14. 2 Nephi 16 / Isaiah 6, 200
   Verse 9--A Condemnatory Phrase Is changed to a Commandment in the KJ, 201

15. 2 Nephi 17 / Isaiah 7, 205
   Verse 18--The KJ Adds Rivers to the Text, 210

16. 2 Nephi 18 / Isaiah 8, 215
   Verse 19--The KJ Justifies the Practice of Spiritualism, 219

17. 2 Nephi 19 / Isaiah 9, 222
   Verse 3--The KJ Adds a Spurious Negative, 223
   Verse 4--The KJ Adds an Explanatory Phrase, 224
   Verse 15--By an Addition, the KJ Eliminates a Segment of the Population From Judgment, 227

18. 2 Nephi 20 / Isaiah l0, 231
   Verse 10--The Founding of Kingdoms by the Lord Is Changed in the KJ to Their Discovery by the Lord, 233

19. 2 Nephi 23 / Isaiah 13, 241
   Verse 3--By Displacing a Comma, the KJ Destroys a Parallelism and Changes the Meaning of the Verse, 241
   Verse 8--The KJ Adds the Example of a Woman in Labor, 245
   Verse 15--The Proud and the Wicked Are Removed in the KJ as the Object of the Vengeance of the Lord Against the Babylonians, 248
   Verse 22--The Promised Destruction of Babylon Is Deleted From the KJ, 251

20. 2 Nephi 24 / Isaiah 14, 253
   Verse 2--The KJ Changes Israel From the Lord's Servants to the Overlords of Servants, 253
   Verse 4--The KJ Deletes the Common B of M Phrase "And it shall come to pass", 256
   Verse 32--In the KJ Version, The Questioned Become the Interrogators, 267

21. Mosiah 14 / Isaiah 53, 269

22. 3 Nephi 20 / Isaiah 52, 274
   Verse 39/6--The B of M Uses a Different Introductory Phrase Because the Preceding Isaiah Verse Was Not Quoted, 276
   Verse 40/7--The Author of the Good Tidings Is Changed in the KJ From Redeemed Israel to the Lord, 277
   Verse 41/11--The Time Setting From the Verse Is Removed From the KJ, 278

23. 3 Nephi 22 / Isaiah 54, 281
   Verse 4--The Reproach of Youth Is Deleted in the KJ, 281
   Verse 15--Opposition to the House of Israel Has Been Deleted From the KJ, 285


Appendix, 288
Bibliography, 291
Index, 296

 

Order Information

Title:

The Legacy of the Brass Plates of Laban--
A Comparison of Biblical & Book of Mormon Texts

Author:

H. Clay Gorton

Retail Price:

$19.98

Available:

Now

ISBN:

0-88290-511-2

Order Number (SKU):

1056

Pages:

298

Size:

6" x 9"

Binding:

Hardbound with jacket

 

 

Horizon Publishers & Distributors, Inc., 191 N. 650 East, Bountiful, UT 84010-3628
Telephone: (801) 295-9451; Fax: (801) 298-1305
E-mail: Service07@HorizonPublishersBookstore.com

All website pages copyright by Horizon Publishers & Distributors, Inc., 2008

Last Update: July, 2008